Serving Columbus & Surrounding Areas Since 1968!

How to Decide Whether to Repair or Replace an Appliance

When your trusted household appliance takes an unexpected nosedive, the “repair or replace an appliance” conundrum suddenly becomes a pressing issue. On some occasions, the decision might be straightforward with repairs being untenable or cost-prohibitive. However, many times you find yourself stuck between a rock and a hard place, contemplating whether to repair an appliance that would cost you half as much as a brand new one. Here are some things to ponder that might lighten your decision-making load.

Should I Repair or Replace an Appliance That’s Not Working Properly?

Every appliance and situation may be different, but more often than not, a repair can be the wiser option. Some older appliances aren’t cost-effective to repair though. here’s how to make the best choice for your home and wallet.

A Quick Diagnostic Run

Before you rush into panic mode and dial your local service provider, let’s eliminate some common culprits:

  • Make sure your appliance is securely plugged in.
  • Regularly clean any vents and filters.
  • Double-check if the circuit breaker hasn’t tripped.
  • If all else fails, the good old ‘unplug and plug back in’ trick might do wonders.
  • Test another nearby outlet for any potential power issues.

Age is More Than a Number

The age of your appliance is a critical determinant when deciding whether to repair or replace an appliance. Keep in mind that:

  • Refrigerators, electric ranges, and dryers usually have a lifespan of around 13 years.
  • A washing machine tends to last for about 10 years.
  • Freezers typically work well for about 11 years.
  • Microwaves and dishwashers have an estimated longevity of nine years.

If your appliance has seen more sunrises than its expected lifespan, replacement might be the sensible choice. But first, check out our tips on how to help your appliances last longer!

is appliance repair worth it

Warranty Wonders

If the warranty on your appliance is still valid, it’s usually more cost-effective to explore the repair route. However, remember that many companies now limit warranty coverage to just one year from the purchase date.

Cost Calculations

One practical guideline when deciding to repair or replace an appliance is comparing the estimated repair cost with the cost of a new unit. If the repair cost exceeds 50% of the cost of a new appliance, it might make more financial sense to opt for a replacement. However, if funds are tight and the repair can extend the appliance’s life for a few more years, repairing could be your best bet.

Trustworthy Track Record

Reliability is key in this decision-making process. If your appliance has been a loyal, problem-free soldier all these years, you might want to invest in its repair, even if it slightly breaches the 50% rule. On the other hand, if it’s had multiple hiccups, it could be time to say goodbye and welcome a new machine into your home.

Energy Efficiency Equation

The potential for improved energy efficiency with a new appliance can sway the “repair or replace an appliance” decision. The energy savings and possible tax credits could make a new purchase worthwhile, especially if you’re planning to stay in your home long-term. For those eyeing a move soon, the short-term energy savings might not justify the cost of a new appliance.

Expensive Fixes Versus Cheap Fixes

Recognize when the cost of repair outweighs the appliance’s value. Time to replace your appliance if your washer refuses to spin, your oven is rusted, your dryer is smoking, or your fridge’s compressor is kaput. Conversely, minor issues like an overheating dryer, a rattling refrigerator, or a dishwasher not filling entirely may be resolved with affordable repairs.

should i repair my appliance

The Downtime Dilemma

Consider the inconvenience and waiting time involved with appliance repair. The repair technician might not have the necessary part readily available, leading to further delays. Weigh the value of your time against the cost of repair.

Taking the Whole Picture into Account

When making the decision to repair or replace an appliance, there are many more factors that need to be taken into consideration beyond the initial cost of the appliance. These include:

  • Disposal: Getting rid of your old appliance can be a hassle, not to mention potentially costly. You’ll need to take into account the logistics of removing your current appliance and any fees associated with its proper disposal.
  • Delivery and Installation: Many new appliances come with additional delivery and installation fees. This is an important factor to remember when comparing the cost of a new appliance versus a repair.
  • Features and Functionality: Upgrading to a new appliance may give you access to advanced features and functionalities, increasing your kitchen’s overall efficiency. It’s worth considering if these enhancements would improve your daily routine.
  • Energy Efficiency: Newer appliances are often more energy-efficient, which not only benefits the environment but can also lead to substantial savings on your energy bills over time.
  • Environmental Consideration: Repairing an existing appliance is usually more eco-friendly than buying a new one. It reduces waste and decreases the use of resources that are required for manufacturing new appliances.

Remember, all these elements should be considered in your cost-benefit analysis when deciding to repair or replace an appliance. Each of these factors can significantly impact the overall cost and benefits associated with your decision.

Wrapping Up

At the end of the day, the “repair or replace an appliance” debate is highly personal, hinging on several factors from your appliance’s condition and age to your financial readiness and even your personal attachment to the machine.

Navigating through this decision-making process can be tough, but remember, you’re not alone. We, at Capital City Appliance Service, Inc., are always ready to assist with your appliance repair needs. Our team of experienced professionals is just a call away, eager to make your appliance dilemma as hassle-free as possible. Get in touch with us today!

Share this Post!


Book Online & Save $10 OFF

Offer valid on the complete repair only. Not valid for service call charge or parts purchase. Cannot be combined with other offers. 

Effective 6/1/2023, using a credit card for payment will incur an additional processing fee.

Need to talk to a customer service rep?

Call 614-308-9028 or Get Online Support

Ready to Schedule Service?

We offer several convenient ways to book your appointment.